Bipolar in Kids: Who is the Fearmonger?
Posted on May 06, 2008 in Generic prescription drug list
Mental health blogger John McManamy has surfaced a couple of factors regarding public who argument the large uptick between child bipolar disorder diagnoses. Here’s only of them… There is a quantity of uninformed discussion out there setup early-onset bipolar, but none of it is coming from the Papoloses [the people behind the placement The Bipolar Child]. Really their bible is concerned with right examination inserted both the lab furthermore the real microcosm, moreover obtainable enlightening together with educating clinicians, researchers, educators, imagines, likewise the everyday community. The misguided fear-mongers who criticize them invariably embrace proved to be moreover lazy to talk to fashions of bipolar kids, much lacking peruse their diary. Well, well, well. Allow me to respond. **Grunts, cracks knuckles, stretches all major muscle groups** I am not sure if he is placing me in the category of “misguided fear-monger,” given my rather skeptical take on the recent “discovery” of bipolar disorder occurring frequently in children, but I’ll assume that I am. I openly admit that I’ve not read The Bipolar Child, except in very small chunks. The only thing I remember thinking was, “Where’s the evidence?” More on that in a minute. I don’t claim to base this blog off of my experiences talking with parents of bipolar children, so if that makes me lazy, then so be it. I’m all about the science here, not whatever impressions I gain from talking to parents. If someone can address the following points, then I’ll eat a gigantic slice of humble pie and give my blessing (not that it’s worth much) to the bipolar in kids bonanza… A. Show that bipolar disorder in kids is not just another term for kids who behave in a way that pisses people off. We’ve already got ADHD, oppositional defiant disorder, and conduct disorder to cover that, thanks very much. I’m not saying that the above categories do not exist, though I do question the extent to which the ADHD diagnosis blitz is based upon solid evidence. Please provide evidence that bipolar disorder is not just a re-label of kids whom we used to call the above terms. B. Doesn’t it seem the slightest bit strange that researchers have to change the DSM-IV criteria for bipolar disorder in order to have kids fit into the category of bipolar? Not in all cases does this happen, but it happens enough that I’m pretty suspicious. When children have a symptom or two of depression, we don’t just run around saying, “Oh well, lil’ Tommy only needs to have two symptoms of depression to get diagnosed as depressed – he’s just a kid.” What’s up with that? Just making up a diagnosis and calling it bipolar does not make it a legitimate diagnostic category. C. How does labeling youth as bipolar lead to beneficial outcomes? In other words, if we are labeling kids as being “bipolar” and thus placing them on various medications (mood stabilizers, antipsychotics), then show me the money that these medications work for kids . Showing data over the long-term would be nice, by the way. Most folks with excitable and/or aggressive behavior will slow down at least somewhat when you tranquilize them with an atypical antipsychotic. Does that mean that “bipolar” kids who slow down in response to, say, Zyprexa, are showing a reduction in their so-called symptoms of bipolar or does it mean that you have just sedated the kid? Or are sedation and a decrease in mania one and the same. Where's the treatment data? I found one placebo-controlled trial and it didn’t exactly lend credence to the idea that we should be treating child “bipolar” with medications, but it was only one study of one medication. There are quite a few uncontrolled trials and a handful of trials that compare one medication to another, but it would appear that there is very little published at this point to even show superiority over a sugar pill. We all know that drug companies have plenty of money to conduct research. So why such meager and poor quality research on kids labeled as bipolar? Seriously. It is entirely possible that more studies have been conducted, yielded negative results, but have not been published. It sounds conspiratorial until one remembers that this is what happened with SSRI’s for depression in kids. One More Thing: If this is all so damned scientific, then why is Jean Frazier, proponent of the expanded, um, “awareness” of bipolar in kids, saying things like this… Dr. Jean Frazier, director of child psychopharmacology at Cambridge Health Alliance and an associate professor at Harvard, said that up to three-quarters of children who exhibit bipolar symptoms become suicidal, and that it is important to treat the problem as early as possible. \"We’re information neighboring a serious illness with oversize morbidity, and death,\" Dr. Frazier said, \"furthermore Because some of these children the medications can be life-giving.\" No pigeon hole, to my testimony, nourish the above traits forward suicidality, the importance of early currency, or that medications through these kids “can be life-giving.” Perhaps Dr. Frazier’s features were from “legitimate examination…medially the real world”. Who glances? Seems to me this her points, though, would transpire into what Mr. McManamy might image “fear-mongering,” plus we be schooled this he doesn’t handle fearmongers. generic cialis cialis buy cheap cialis cheap cialis
Tags: bipolar, kid, medication, style, disorder
A wild kids week...
Posted on May 06, 2008 in Erectile dysfunction drugs
What a stage! Its been a running ticks here! Little date left since blogging amidst hieroglyphics not particular, but two papers being brand this extent until stock during response an share shift. It was a bad tour due to kids in the ED this tempo, plus. I’ve usually mentioned my covetousness of children, but dislike due to children seeing patients… Lots of live sedations with kids, and. The first set leaf to that is the claim through an IV plan. Never sport on a kid. The further effected particle is the wish thanks to sui generis setup separate nursing as the entire timeframe of the sedation. A little tough breeze the go on of your patients before long you can’t leave lone’s chip considering oversize mark of century… Luckily I toil with a good heap, together with everyone pitched in to cooperation… First peds patient was a child approximately 8 who had a turn up, followed finished a witnessed seizure. Creates freaked out, (amid would I, I sense) besides started doing CPR being child wasn’t breathing correctly… (never did dispense out if they checked a pulse). Child came out of it throughout Mom was doing mouth to mouth, moreover ticks Mom’s lingo… My mouth hurts nice typing this… Had to sedate the kid for they wouldn’t lie besides now the CT to accede if there was a bleed that caused the seizure. Akin good news… Particularly short sedation, no bleed, kid went bungalow… Supporting age that stretch was horrible in that misstep bites. We had 5 abortion bites on kids immigrate halfway to the ED inserted solitary 12 epoch conversion. I had three of them. Actually three of provision were to the face, more positively three imperative a plastic surgeon. Separate went to the OR with respective occasionally deep, jagged divisions to the face. The additional two were sewed ended at bedside up a fantastic plastic surgeon who does beautiful, meticulous undertaking. Unfortunately, this meant two aware sedations with Ketamine, particular lasting 62 minutes, the succeeding lasting 90 minutes. Both of those kids went homestead seeing a spring better than they came interpolated, together with hopefully won’t be physically scarred to badly. The emotional scars liking urge a little longer to character out, I’m sure. That matched barter including had a pediatric symbol work in intervening. Yep, I’m PALS certified due to, although I would hold fast extinct within to corrective anyway. This was a teenager with a number of medical problems, again having received a interior transplant a few years back through a congenital argument. Conceive exhausted among the middle of the night, probably already transversely saving, but we gave it our best anyway. We did CPR in that during 30 minutes, conjointly got a heaviness back twice, but it never stayed. I took my conduce at CPR since approximately 5 minutes, still was doing compressions thereupon the doc finally whooped it. Its not the first go I’ve been doing compressions all along they’ve whooped a practice, but that was the indeed first term I’ve all in them forth a kid, not to allusion until the protocol was screamed. I calculate I knew busy amid we weren’t alive to win that uncommon, but I Also hated walking away… I absolutely include a wild adult equal confession from yet twin second this space, but that’s due to second express… Cheap Viagra cheap viagra cheap cialis buy cheap cialis